Solution businesses were priced on tools the customer lacked. AI hands the customer the tools.

Manufacturers aimed to move from selling products to selling outcomes because they held the software, the data and the expertise to run them, and customers accepted the dependency. AI has the potential to make much of that layer cheap and adaptable on the customer's side. The part that solved a problem the customer could never solve alone still holds. The part that was convenient because the customer lacked the tools is likely to be repriced first, and as a consequence the operating model has to follow.

For most of the industrial century the way to grow was scale. Bigger plants and broader distribution paid, but producing more still meant consuming more material, labour and capital. Software and cloud broke that link for the companies that sold software, and manufacturers tried to borrow the effect by selling solutions instead of products. Rolls-Royce sold engine hours rather than engines. SKF managed the customer's bearing inventory rather than shipping bearings. The pitch was recurring revenue and a closer relationship, and customers went along with it because the supplier held the software, the data and the expertise needed to run the service.

AI changes the second half of that sentence. It changes what suppliers can produce, but perhaps more importantly, it changes what customers need to buy.

A solution contract bundles three things that are usually discussed as one. The first is the physical asset and the network that services it. The second is the risk the supplier takes on, with availability guaranteed and downtime paid for by the supplier. The third is the information layer, the monitoring, optimisation, recommendations and reporting that tell the customer what to do and when. AI is likely to put pressure on the information layer first. Much of it, the convenience layer, was convenient to buy only because the customer lacked the tools to do it alone. The asset, the service network and the transferred risk still solve problems the customer cannot solve alone. When the convenience layer is repriced, the supplier's pricing, service organisation and sales have to follow.

Why the dependency was accepted

Customers accepted the bundle because the information layer was expensive to build and needed specialists they did not employ. A plant manager could in principle have run his own bearing analytics. In practice the model, the data pipeline and the people to interpret it cost more than the premium SKF charged for doing it. The convenience was priced in, and nobody had a cheaper option to compare it with.

What AI makes cheap, and what it does not

Capabilities that once needed a large budget and a specialist vendor are becoming cheap and adaptable on the customer's side. Most customers will not build their own systems, and many should not. But the option now exists, and an option changes a negotiation even when it is never exercised.

Three uses are already visible. A customer can optimise across several suppliers instead of inside one supplier's platform, which removes the quiet advantage of being the system the customer looks at every morning. It can test the supplier's recommendations against its own model and see where the two disagree. And it can build enough of the information layer to know what the rest should cost. The customer may well keep buying from you after all three. It buys with better information, and the margin that sat in the convenience layer goes with it.

Two things limit how much of the information layer the customer can reproduce, and they decide where the repricing stops.

The first is the data. AI gives the customer the model. It does not give the customer the data if the data is generated by the supplier's sensors, held on the supplier's platform and licensed back under the service agreement. In many installed-base businesses that is the real moat, and it was built almost by accident. It is unlikely to stay accidental. Data access, portability and the right to run your own models on your own operating data will probably move from the appendix of the service agreement into the first negotiation round, because the customer now has the tools to notice what it is missing.

The second is judgment. The customer can reproduce the model, but not yet the knowledge of what a reading means for one plant, with its history and maintenance habits. That still sits mostly in the heads of the supplier's engineers, and a customer running its own model without that context will be wrong in ways it cannot see. How long that lasts differs by industry. Where the supplier's engineers are also the ones who turn up when something breaks, it may last a long time.

The same shift works in the supplier's favour on one axis. AI lowers the cost of the model for everyone and raises the value of the data the model runs on. A supplier with ten thousand installations has operating data no single customer can assemble from its own plant, e.g. failure patterns, the effect of a maintenance regime across hundreds of sites, or what a reading means for this machine given what it meant for the other nine thousand. So margin moves out of the convenience layer, which the customer can now reproduce, and into the cross-installation layer, which it cannot. Suppliers that hold on to the customer's own data will defend the convenience layer and lose it. Suppliers that hand it over freely and compete on what the whole installed base teaches give up a small position to take a larger one.

The three parts do not move together

The three parts of the bundle are repriced at different speeds, and the two standard examples show it.

In the engine business the lock-in was never mainly informational. The airline cannot certify an engine, cannot stand up a global maintenance network and does not want the availability risk back. AI gives it a better view of what it is paying for and a stronger hand on scope and price at renewal. The contract is therefore likely to be renegotiated rather than replaced.

Bearing inventory management carries more of its value in the information layer and in logistics. The customer owns the machines, the sensors can be anyone's and the logistics are close to a commodity. What the supplier keeps is the knowledge of how bearings fail in that installed base and the reliability of the service itself. The analytics premium is the part AI reprices first, because the problem it solved was a lack of tools rather than a lack of possibility.

The same split runs inside each company's offer. How much of the information layer was convenience, and how much rests on cross-installation data and engineering judgment the customer cannot assemble? The convenience layer is likely to be repriced at the speed model costs fall. The asset, the service network and the transferred risk are repriced far more slowly. Most solution portfolios contain all three, priced as one.

The operating model has to follow

Separating the three parts is a pricing exercise first. A solution priced as one bundle hides which part the customer is paying for. When the customer can price the information layer itself, the bundle unravels from the inside. Pricing the asset, the risk and the information separately, at least internally, shows where the margin sits and how much of it is exposed.

The service organisation follows the pricing. A unit sized for a world where the supplier interprets everything is too large for a world where the customer interprets half of it. The people who remain handle what the customer still cannot, the exceptions, the physical intervention and the liability.

Sales changes last and hardest. Part of solution selling was the creation of dependency, and sales organisations were paid to deepen it, even where the contract also transferred real risk and improved the asset. Selling to a customer that can check your numbers is a different job. The claim has to be verifiable. The outcome has to be one the customer can measure with its own tools. The premium has to be explainable in terms of what the customer could not have done alone.

The economics describe the direction. The timing depends on model costs, on who owns the sensors and on how many customers have the people to use the option, so it differs by industry. A supplier that reprices itself before the customers can gives away margin. One that waits for the customers to do it gives away the terms.

Where the argument may not hold

It assumes customers want the option. Many procurement organisations are built to buy outcomes, and the people in them have no incentive to take back a risk they successfully pushed out. The repricing is therefore likely to come from customers with operations people in the room, and unevenly. A supplier will see it first in a few accounts and may mistake that for a few difficult customers.